The quadratic polynomial
has integer coefficients, with . It satisfies for every integer , but for at least one real number .
A student writes
where , and chooses an integer nearest to , so that .
Which of the following arguments validly rules out every integer with ?
ASince , we have . If , this implies , a contradiction.
BBecause the coefficients are integers, is an integer. Thus , so if then , a contradiction.
CFor an integer nearest to , we always have . Thus , so .
DThe number is a positive integer, so . Hence . If , then , a contradiction.
EThe inequalities and give . Since , this forces , so .
FSince and , we have . If , then , contradicting .