Official papers

Official Specimen Paper 2 · Q3

Paper 2Logic & proofAlgebra

Consider the following attempt to solve an equation. The steps have been numbered for reference.

x+5=x+3⇓(1)x+5=x2+6x+9⇓(2)x2+5x+4=0⇓(3)(x+4)(x+1)=0x=−4 or x=−1\begin{gathered} \sqrt{x+5}=x+3\\ \Downarrow\quad\text{(1)}\\ x+5=x^2+6x+9\\ \Downarrow\quad\text{(2)}\\ x^2+5x+4=0\\ \Downarrow\quad\text{(3)}\\ (x+4)(x+1)=0\\ x=-4\text{ or }x=-1 \end{gathered}

Which one of the following statements is true?

ABoth −4-4 and −1-1 are solutions of the equation.
BNeither −4-4 nor −1-1 are solutions of the equation.
COne solution is correct and the incorrect solution arises as a result of step (1).
DOne solution is correct and the incorrect solution arises as a result of step (2).
EOne solution is correct and the incorrect solution arises as a result of step (3).

Read the questions freely. Sign in to check your answer, see the worked solution and save your progress.