Official papers

Official 2018 Paper 2 · Q9

Paper 2Logic & proofAlgebra

Consider the following attempt to solve the equation 4x2x−1=10x−54x\sqrt{2x-1}=10x-5:

4x2x−1=10x−5⇓(I)4x2x−1=5(2x−1)⇓(II)16x2(2x−1)=25(2x−1)2⇓(III)16x2=25(2x−1)⇓(IV)16x2−50x+25=0⇓(V)(8x−5)(2x−5)=0⇓(VI)\begin{gathered} 4x\sqrt{2x-1}=10x-5\\[2pt] \underset{\text{(I)}}{\Downarrow}\\[2pt] 4x\sqrt{2x-1}=5(2x-1)\\[2pt] \underset{\text{(II)}}{\Downarrow}\\[2pt] 16x^2(2x-1)=25(2x-1)^2\\[2pt] \underset{\text{(III)}}{\Downarrow}\\[2pt] 16x^2=25(2x-1)\\[2pt] \underset{\text{(IV)}}{\Downarrow}\\[2pt] 16x^2-50x+25=0\\[2pt] \underset{\text{(V)}}{\Downarrow}\\[2pt] (8x-5)(2x-5)=0\\[2pt] \underset{\text{(VI)}}{\Downarrow} \end{gathered}

The solutions of the original equation are x=58x=\frac58 and x=52x=\frac52.

Which one of the following is true?

AThe solution is correct.
BOnly one of x=58x=\frac58 and x=52x=\frac52 is correct and the error arises as a result of step (II).
COnly one of x=58x=\frac58 and x=52x=\frac52 is correct and the error arises as a result of step (III).
DOnly one of x=58x=\frac58 and x=52x=\frac52 is correct and the error arises as a result of step (IV).
EThere is another value of xx that satisfies the original equation and the error arises as a result of step (II).
FThere is another value of xx that satisfies the original equation and the error arises as a result of step (III).
GThere is another value of xx that satisfies the original equation and the error arises as a result of step (IV).

Read the questions freely. Sign in to check your answer, see the worked solution and save your progress.